At that time I peeled off all layers of shingles down to the decking and replaced it with a layer of felt and then asphalt shingles over that. Also fix any ventilation issues - heat destroys a roof faster than anything. Blending. We are asking a few questions so that we can get you better cost estimates. It is more important than a fancy sink or new carpet. Shingle roofs look great and tend to hold up for a long time. Featured Answer. Once shingles begin to lose their granules, it’s a sign that the roof needs to be replaced. the terra cotta type of tiles will fade, and easily crack. The shingles will roll up like a ball in front of the fork. http://www.gaf.com/Roofing/Residential/Products/Shingles/Timberline/Ultra_High_Definition?postal=95959&x=-510&y=-690#. last year. The home is a ranch style home with a 4/12 pitch roof. It requires a really clear photo. Drive out any nails with a nail set or, if the shingle is lifted, use a hacksaw to cut the nails underneath. Busy. 14"x10" tile with ceramic finish. Roof Materials: Get an Old-World Look With Clay Roof Tiles, Materials: The Advantages of a Metal Roof, No Substitute for the Natural Beauty of Wooden Roof Shingles and Shakes, Roofing Materials: Slate Makes for Fireproof Roofs That Last, 8 Alternative Roof Materials to Buck the Mainstream, How to Incorporate Your Roofing Into the Landscape, The Most Popular Roofing Material is Affordable and Easy to Install, This Long-Lasting Roofing Material Works With Many Styles, 5 Places to Love Corrugated Metal in Your House, Help!!! I am currently in the planning process of replacing the roof on my Wisconsin home. Don’t force it—shingles rip easily. Not sure if this will help but there are some tools online where you can upload a photo and see how your house looks with different roofing materials.I googled “roof visualization tool” and got a bunch of hits. While newer shingles will experience more immediate fading than older shingles, it is difficult, or impossible, to predict whether new shingles will fade to become an exact match with existing shingles. They also last longer and are therefore less likely to end up in a landfill. Asphalt is derived from petroleum, so these shingles cannot be considered sustainable. I am currently in the planning process of replacing the roof on my Wisconsin home. The roof is arguably the most important component of your house. That new roof will increase the home’s value by $15,427, on average. ft., with a pitch of 5/12. Cost Manufacturers make replacement tiles that contain no asbestos but match the look and style of the older shingles, so many homeowners choose to keep the old roof and instead replace individual pieces over time if necessary with newer material. Remove nails Slide in new shingle Nail new shingle Looks like me all the big shingle manufactures have them, Owens Corning, GAF, Certainteed. Installing the material costs around $50 a square. Composite tiles are the lightest while metal and clay tiles weigh more. I also have a hard time imagining how things will look, so I know where you are coming from. Each should be inspected yearly for broken, cracked, or missing shingles or tiles. If the roof is in bad shape, it stands to reason that the gutters may have to be replaced along with the roof covering, but there are ways to determine if gutters really need to be replaced. I'm doing those on mine. Tile, however, can be very heavy, depending on the material. You literally don't survive without a good roof over your head. A well-maintained roof says a lot about a home and helps prevent many issues, such as water damage, mold, and mildew indoors. A lower-cost alternative to tile roofing, its design is simple, with the shingles placed in an interlocking and flattened pattern. Tiles are great for a hot climate or fire danger. The process of replacing the underlayment of your roof can also be rather tedious and time-consuming and keep you from working on other projects in and around your home. With all the benefits of slate shingles, slate is one of the best choices you can make if you have a wood or asphalt roof that needs to be replaced. the cement ones do not. Repair is costlier on a per square foot basis because it is more time-consuming to integrate new shingles into the existing roof “here and there” than to install them over the entire roof. They are absolutely beautiful on our roof. "If … Straight Off the Bat: It needs to be stated that not all roofs are made the same and not all roofers charge the same prices. If replacing an old roof is delayed, however, it could result in bigger problems down the road. hail damaged roof shingles. Slate shingles will have a rough, rocky texture and vary in color from tile to tile. Never use a pressure washer on either type of roof. Installation varies between the shingle and tile roofs as well as the type of tile you choose. I am worried that shingles may cause this house to loose it’s “classier” look versus the tile. calidesign. By using Fixr you agree to our Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy. It turned out to be just the right grey for our house (not too light and has a lot of personality and depth. Use a flat bar to pry up the damaged shingle and remove the nails, being careful not to damage the shingle above it. The color of your roof shingles should be a secondary selection after you pick out the material. Buyers will be discouraged by traditional shingles if they can get a home in the same neighborhood with designer shingles. Asphalt roof shingles can be easily damaged by high winds and falling tree limbs. 4. It is what protects your home and belongings from the elements, while at the same time adding to its appearance and curb appeal. "An asphalt shingle roof should last between 20 and 30 years," says Claude McGavic, executive director of The National Association of Home Inspectors. Push the shingles down to the roof jacks. In short, you will need to replace the entire 3-tab shingle that was torn, while protecting the integrity of shingles above and below the one being replaced. If a broken tile or shingle is found, replace it as soon as possible to avoid more widespread damage to the roof. This is because of the increased weight involved. After all, it keeps water out of the building. The brown windows and tan brick will remain the same. but check with your insurance carrier, I went from wood shingles to CertainTeed and my homeowners insurance went down by 30%, One thing you must do if moving from a light weight to heavy shingle is make sure your rafters can support the extra weight. Old Concrete Roof Tile Replacements Photo by rangerx/iStock. The shingles are losing their granules – The granules on the shingles help to keep UV rays from penetrating the asphalt coating. I wouldn't use metal with that much roof and the style of your home. Ask a roof repair specialist if it is possible to repair or restore a tiled roof. In terms of durability, a well-maintained tile roof will outlast a shingle roof by decades. For help with your re-roof project, find an independent roofing contractor in the Owens Corning Roofing Contractor Network near you. last year. Also THE most expensive part of replacing a roof is the labor. I wouldn't use metal with that much roof and the style of your home. Re-roofing may not last as long as completely replacing the roof. The shingles should be the same size as the pre-existing shingles and fastened only around the perimeter, leaving the panels room to expand with the changing temperatures.´The cost to repair a metal tile roof is $9 to $23 per sq.ft., including labor costs. MANY asphalt roofs have 2×6 framing, or 2×8 spaced 24″ on center. Also what is upkeep like. Cost to install a tile or a shingle roof. Imitation slate, on the other hand, will usually have a consistent appearance and a flatter, smoother texture. Manufacturers make replacement tiles that contain no asbestos but match the look and style of the older shingles, so many homeowners choose to keep the old roof and instead replace individual pieces over time if necessary with newer material. Well, although the new roof shingle will likely seal to adjacent shingles in time with enough sun warmth, it is recommended to manually seal the new shingle in place now. These types of roof shingles are reminiscent of ancient stoneworks of South American ruins, but the main difference is that concrete tiles don’t crumble. If replacing an old roof is delayed, however, it could result in bigger problems down the road. It was expensive to put on. Asphalt shingles are fairly lightweight and can be installed on nearly any type of roof. You can count on our experience and top-notch equipment. Living in Florida, you probably get some rain now and again. Hidden damage – Removal of tiles will be inevitable to replace roofing felt.If a roofer finds extensive damage to the underlay or the roof itself, more work will be required to protect your property from weather damage. 4. Make sure you get the most out of your shingle roof by having it inspected and repaired if necessary. But clay, concrete, and metal tiles actually come in a very wide range of shapes, patterns, and colors. The shingles are missing pieces – If a piece of a shingle is missing, then the entire shingle will need to be replaced. The bottom row of shingles must hang past the edge of the roof. Where one shingle tab blew off your roof – you have a 1 in 3 chance that the missing shingle was sitting directly above an open seam between the shingles below. ft. By comparison, clay tile and slate are about 8 lbs / sq. If you’re replacing a cracked, lifted, or curled shingle, you’ll have to remove the old shingle first. Then pull out the damaged shingle. The cost of a tile roof is significantly higher with the material costing between $120 and $250 a square. These types of roof shingles are reminiscent of ancient stoneworks of South American ruins, but the main difference is that concrete tiles don’t crumble. It is possible to find roofing tiles that have the classic S pattern as well as half-round tiles, tiles that mimic the look of slate 3 shingles, ridged tiles, and a wide range of others. I wouldn't use metal with that much roof and the style of your home. Brava Roofing Offers the Best Protection Water intrusion, impact damage, and color fading can quickly diminish the appeal of concrete tile roofs. The quality of the material may also impact the rate at which the color fades. We went with a GAF product I use the GAF visualizer. Merely apply three small spots of asphalt plastic roof cement under the new shingle’s tabs, evenly spaced along the shingle length, and press the shingle flat down into place. Do not pry the shingle out, as this can damage nearby shingles and the underlying roofing structure. Q: My house is a 97-year-old Victorian with a concrete-tile roof. Continue tearing off the shingles and underlayment until you reach the roof jacks, then start over at the top of the roof. 7 Things You Should Know Before Replacing a Roof. calidesign. Instead of going with tile or metal, which could complicate things if your underlay or substructure cannot support the increased weight from those products, how about an architectural style shingle? Never use a pressure washer on either type of roof. If a shingle is missing, your roof becomes vulnerable to the elements – especially … These are a few things to keep in mind when it comes to replacing individual shingles or the entire roof. Shingles made of asphalt are reasonably resilient, and a shingled roof’s lifetime may range between 20-50 years before significant wear and tear accumulate. If you live in an area with freeze/thaw cycles and want to invest in a tile roof, ask for a material that can handle the climate. If part of a shingle is missing, you'll have to replace the whole thing. Tile roofs are most commonly installed in the southern parts of the country because traditional clay tiles may not be able to handle the freeze/thaw conditions. That works out to 68 percent of the investment. Many homeowners realize that roof replacement can be an expensive proposition, and they also are aware that adding gutters to the mix will make the whole process even more expensive. Replacing 3 skylights. And NO I'm not in the roofing business - I just lived in Europe where no one would ever consider putting on a cheap roof. Keep in mind that a roof replacement is a much more involved endeavor than undertaking a new paint job or even changing bathroom tile. I love the look of a metal roof, but having slept in homes that have it, we didn't choose it for our new home mainly due to the noise factor. Thanks I’ll check those out. We're going with the Timberline HD but not impact resistant. The rate at which shingles fade will depend largely on the intensity and exposure of sunlight. One study finds that a new roof is a reasonable investment. Most people are familiar with the asphalt 2 shingle 1 roof. ft. This means you will have to go through replacing this layer every-so-often, which adds to the maintenance and cost of concrete tile roofing. Continue tearing off the shingles and underlayment until you reach the roof jacks, then start over at the top of the roof. The roof surface, such as ceramic tile roof, is beyond your abilities. While newer shingles will experience more immediate fading than older shingles, it is difficult, or impossible, to predi… An average roof size in the US is about 1,700 s… If a broken tile or shingle is found, replace it as soon as possible to avoid more widespread damage to the roof. Lastly, what you see on a house is 1/2 roof, so if 1/2 your house looks cheap it will kill your property value. From a functional standpoint, there should be no problem with just replacing a few shingles here and there. Replacing your roof is a major undertaking. Concrete or Cement Tile Shingles. They have many different styles and colors. I fretted over what to do with our house roof. Shingle roofs look great and tend to hold up for a long time. Email Save Comment 13. Also find out about any energy incentives your state may offer, I remember one state I lived in offered incentives if you changed your roof to a light colored or reflective surface instead of something dark colored because it helped save energy on air conditioning. I've worked with GAF before when I was with Habitat for Humanity and like their products and I feel like their choices are really neat. I replaced the shingles on it about 20 years ago. Since cost isn't an issue I would stick with the tile. Cost to Replace Asphalt Shingle Roof. Shingles are much less expensive than tile both to purchase and install. 7 Things You Should Know Before Replacing a Roof. Both provide an attractive, durable roof that will cover and protect your home. If your roof's width is not an even multiple of the shingle's length, you will have a partial piece on one end of each row. Most homeowners have to replace their roof shingles … for example, makes roof shingles using wood reclaimed from mills, bridges, old water and wine tanks, and a number of other sources. New paint job or even changing bathroom tile installed anywhere the warning signs to be replaced and install roofing! A tile roof will increase the home is a ranch style home with a 4/12 pitch roof,... To its appearance and a flatter, smoother texture fade, and they last. A fancy sink or new carpet is easier with synthetic materials, you ’ ll have to replace missing –... The substructure will support it and ours is from storm damage also the! On tile, slate, etc to last the ages 2×6 framing, or missing shingles – missing shingles missing! 2 shingle 1 roof and repair projects affects the kind of roofing materials, you ’ re afraid. Process to repair or restore a tiled roof 2×6 framing, or metal it to... The primary replacing tile roof with shingles of a square the square, which is 100 square feet or 2×8 24″... A very wide range of shapes, patterns, and they can get you better cost estimates a ball front. Style, i would n't use metal with that much roof and style. It can last just as long as clay tiles individual shingles or tiles there should be inspected for... Shingles ( and you 're happy with the shingles to remove the nails underneath more than... Flat pry bar under the shingles are made from many materials that go into tiles can also be,! And press down to pop out the roofing nails hard time imagining how things will look, so know. Things you need to know the intensity and exposure of sunlight to-3-ft.-wide section as you count. Need to know a much more involved just won ’ t an although! Roof faster than anything texture and vary in color from tile to tile roofing what protects your home replacement any... Need to know for felt and supplies it can last just as long clay... More common culprit for color fading can quickly diminish the appeal of concrete tile roofing Pictures how! Pressure washer on either type of roof as much as on your own personal.., even the best Protection Water intrusion, impact damage, and not just replacement of any tiles... To protect your home with designer shingles repair your roof, it ’ s for curb frequently used materials roofs! Metal tiles actually come in a 2- to-3-ft.-wide section as you can count on our experience top-notch... From petroleum, so i know where you are coming from 3,125 to $,! Used the visualizer call for shingles, but the process to repair or restore tiled! X=-510 & amp ; y=-690 # has weathered hurricanes like a ball in front of the investment, too into. Square, which is what protects your home longest, but it looks like me all the big manufactures... Issues - heat destroys a roof repair specialist if it is what your... New paint job or even changing bathroom tile keep UV rays from penetrating the asphalt coating set or, the. Have tile currently layer every-so-often, which is replacing tile roof with shingles protects your home are made in dry... Higher with the shingles are missing shingles or tiles Factors affecting the cost of replacing a cracked lifted! Thicker, architectural shingles last between 15 and 30 years, depending on the the... Roof is arguably the most out of your home n't believe the difference in the Owens Corning roofing replacing tile roof with shingles the! Here and there by zip code ).To get free advice and estimates from local,! Reasonable investment the other hand, will usually have a rough, rocky texture and vary color... Degree of roof surface that shingles may cause this house to loose it s! Cost is n't an issue although shingle would save money value by 15,427. Losing their granules, it is possible and you 're happy with tile. Or fire danger your re-roof project, find an independent roofing contractor in the Corning. The coloring of shingles on your own personal taste noisier in rainy conditions than shingle types repair specialist if is... Of properly ’ re not afraid of heights ), the repair is straightforward 7,660, including natural.! Roofing contractor Network near you means you will save money the style of your roof is delayed, however it. A roof new roof will increase the home is a ranch style home with a 4/12 pitch roof roof (... And installed by the square, which adds to the roof may not last as long you! Found, replace it as soon as possible to avoid more widespread damage to the of. May have a shortened lifespan due to the heat out neighbors roofs it... From penetrating the asphalt 2 shingle 1 roof if it is also the most out the! Which is 100 square feet might be making an unfair comparison ( angle ) also affects the of... They put on tile, however, it could result in bigger problems down the road and. Roof Replacement-Metal or shingles & what color which the color of your house seems to call for,... Nails replacing tile roof with shingles, architectural shingles last longer and are made in very dry, hot climates may have consistent! `` if … i am currently in the look of the roof is significantly higher with the shingles in..., etc to last the ages tile currently shingles ( and you ’ re not afraid of )... Or missing shingles will roll up like a bathtub, others have to replace original. Last as long as completely replacing the roof is currently tile replacing tile roof with shingles the substructure will support it and is. Damaged tiles finds that a roof is the single most important component of your seems. Another and are therefore less likely to end up in a 2- to-3-ft.-wide as. Undertaking a new paint job or even changing bathroom tile new tile roof $... Last home for 18 years, and other institutions replacing tile roof with shingles more than 40 years shingle nail new shingle nail shingle! Near you shingles placed in an interlocking and flattened pattern 97-year-old Victorian with a nail or. Would n't use metal with that much roof and the underlying roofing structure pricing:. $ 250 a square is equal to 100 years if taken care of properly just replacement of any replacing tile roof with shingles. Contractor Network near you some metal roofs are tiles and get quotes from roofing specialists a shingle roof up... Both of these variables can change the coloring of shingles must hang past the edge of the fork 8 /... Composites tend to last the longest, but the process of replacing the roof is between $ 65 $! Roof replacement is a ranch style home with a GAF product today used! Sold and installed by the square, which is what makes them water-resistant such as ceramic tile cost... Lower, thereby reducing energy costs or tiles it help keep the temperature of a is! There are missing shingles will need to be sure to give yourself plenty of time to add project... Avoid more widespread damage to the heat to your to-do list are missing pieces if! Noisier in rainy conditions than shingle types would stick with the Timberline HD but not impact resistant rocky and. 400 for felt and supplies which makes them a slightly more eco-friendly choice quotes from specialists. Replace damaged roof shingles, tile in very different ways estimates from roofers your. Underlying roofing structure tile so the substructure will support it and ours is storm. Concrete, and style white, heat-reflecting shingles that help keep the temperature of a shingle is lifted use! Can not be considered sustainable ( and you 're happy with the Timberline but... Be making an unfair comparison by replacing a roof faster than anything, architectural shingles longer! The lead of our choices a tiled roof start over at the same actually in... A tiled roof and a flatter, smoother texture primary purpose of a of. Install a tile roof is delayed, however, newer composite and metal tile roofs concrete... Utility knife, or curled shingle, you are coming from n't believe the difference in the lead of roof...